Everyone who fishes has their go-to tackle already set up in the tackle box. Sometimes you may want to veer away from the standard and aim for something new. When you’ve reached that point, there’s no better way to find new tackle than by subscribing to a monthly tackle service. No doubt you’ve come across more than one Mystery Tackle Box review while researching new tackle.

Adding new tools and accessories to the tackle box is a constant job for the evolving angler. With such a perpetual task, it's important for anglers to explore new and exciting options whenever they can.

What exactly is a Mystery Tackle Box, though?

Mystery Tackle Box

The first thing to be covered for this Mystery Tackle Box review is what precisely the product in question is. What it contains, the general delivery time, and what you're signing up for when you make your purchase.

Mystery Tackle Box will send you monthly boxes filled with specially curated tackle. Customers can pick tackle meant to catch six different species of fish to ensure that you aren't receiving tackle that has no use for your favored fish.

Three separate boxes are offered at different prices, charged depending on the plan picked.

Ultimately, Mystery Tackle Box is a fantastic way to round out your tackle selection with options you may not have considered beforehand. They offer a beginner's package for amateur anglers that aren't sure where to start or those who just want a great starter pack on some new tackle.

With the basics covered, let's dive in for a closer look.

Mystery Tackle Box Review: Opening the Box

As previously stated, each month will contain different tackle so that customers won't be receiving the same handful of lures and accessories over and over again. That aside, we can get a good idea of the quality of the accessories anglers can expect by examining past boxes.

Past offerings

With angling, the vast majority of accessories will be consumable. Companies often make realistic baits of flexible, elastic material that can be nibbled away at by fish, and even the best hook or rod won't last forever.

Because of this, anglers should expect the life of the materials inside of the box to be dependent on the frequency of use.

An excellent resource is Mystery Tackle Box's own website, where they list past boxes and provide pictures of the contents. Through this, we can see that arguably the most common item offered is, of course, various bits of tackle.

Hooks, lures, and jiggers are most of what you'll find inside of your box, along with a few stickers and other cosmetic items. Sometimes anglers can find some literature and nature references to help identify or chase different catches.

High quality

While it depends on the month offered, most customers applaud the high quality of the tackle provided. As the items are consumable, one shouldn't expect them to be indestructible or last forever.

That said, as far as tackle goes, anglers can rest easy with sharp, sturdy hooks and lifelike tackle to help with their targeted species.

Why Mystery Tackle Box?

This may be a Mystery Tackle Box review, but that doesn't mean it's the only thing we'll be mentioning. It's important for anglers to know their options so that they know what makes Mystery Tackle Box stand out amongst the competitors.

In a moment, we'll cover a few competitors to see what makes it stand out. Before we can do that, let's reel in some more detail on the product at hand.

Flexible offerings

One of the greatest draws of Mystery Tackle Box is the ability to pick from different species to have your tackle tailored towards. When signing up for a box, anglers pick one of six species from the following:

  • Bass (largemouth, smallmouth, spotted)
  • Trout (rainbow, brown, brook, cutthroat)
  • Inshore saltwater (redfish, speckled trout, snook, flounder)
  • Panfish (crappie, bluegill, perch)
  • Catfish (blue, channel, flathead)
  • Walleye (walleye, sauger)

Being able to focus your product towards a specific species stops you from having to worry about getting a box of entirely useless tackle. What good is getting tackle aimed towards fly fishing when your favored terrain is deep sea fishing?

More boxes!

Another flexible option is that there are three separate boxes: Regular, Pro, and Elite -- costing $16.99, $26.99, and $36.99 per month, respectively. The higher the package you pick, the higher the quality and quantity you can expect in your box.

Regular and Pro both have all of the above six species as options, whereas Elite is primarily for bass with an offering for "multi-species," including bass, panfish, and catfish.

Added to this, there are four payment plans offered:

  • Monthly
  • 3-month
  • 6-month
  • 12-month

More than just committing to a larger number of boxes, you'll save more overall by subscribing for months.

If you're on rough times, or if you just want to try out the service, paying monthly is a fantastic option. If you've been satisfied with what you've seen, or are ready for a full commitment, then paying more up front for more boxes will save money by the end of it all.

Finally, as touched on before, Mystery Tackle Box offers a beginner's series. This package is focused on freshwater species and offers techniques and tips from experts to help beginners raise their abilities as fast as possible.

You can only get a 3-month plan, but there are few better offerings out there for those just starting to get hooked and wanting to explore the options.

Mystery Tackle Box Review: How We Reviewed

It isn't hard to find a Mystery Tackle Box review from enthusiastic anglers, bloggers, and professional product reviewers. That makes it so that there's little ambiguity on the quality and public opinion of the product.

It's important to check third party and unaffiliated sources to avoid getting reviews that are simply trying to hype up a product. That said, we curated dozens of reviews to have the best, most accurate representation of what anglers had to say in their own Mystery Tackle Box review.

What the People Say

With almost six thousand reviews on Trustpilot, Mystery Tackle Box has a rating of 5.0 out of 5.0 stars, with 80 percent of all reviews being excellent, the highest ranking with Trustpilot's system. "Poor" and "Bad," the lowest rankings, add together to be only three percent of total reviews.

Tacklescout gives it a slightly less favorable score while still giving it an incredibly high standing at 8.8 out of 10. More than anything, they applaud the great value and fantastic selection of baits available. It comes highly recommended to those that want to diversify their selection of baits and tackles especially.

Finally, Askmen awards Mystery Tackle Box a 4.5 out of 5. As with Tacklescout, the curation of baits and tackles comes specifically highlighted.

As many bloggers and customers do, a massive highlight is how easy Mystery Tackle Box makes it to pause or end your subscription in case you end up not needing any tackle for a month or two.

Dozens of individual bloggers and customers have weighed in on these websites and others to add their voice to an incredibly positive public opinion of Mystery Tackle Box. Overall, it comes as one of the most highly spoken of fishing tackle subscription services on the market today.

Still, a Mystery Tackle Box review wouldn't be complete without looking at the competition.

Casting for Competitors

Now that we know exactly what we're getting into with a Mystery Tackle Box, it's time to look across the market and see what else could be drawn in. With competitors, we're looking specifically for services that offer a similar, if not identical, business model to what Mystery Tackle Box offers.

It's essential to know these options to ensure that you pick the best possible service, rather than just the one that advertisers have hyped up the most.


PostFly is decently popular with their customer base with an average rating of 4.1 out of 5 stars, according to Cratejoy.

image via postfly.com

The company touts it "the original flybox," which helps us see the most important comparison against Mystery Tackle Box; PostFly is specifically for fly fishing, which may not fit everyone's style. If you're looking for fly fishing supplies and monthly gear, then PostFly comes highly recommended.

They're a bit pricier with subscriptions at $19.99 and $39.95 a month and offer fewer options than Mystery Tackle Box, but they're still a highly praised and well-respected subscription service for anglers looking to join in with the fly fishing community.

Sportsman's Box

First things first: Sportsman's Box isn't focused specifically on fishing as the others in this Mystery Tackle Box review are. Rather, Sportsman's Box focuses on hunting and fishing, meaning that you're just as likely to get something meant for hunters as you are for anglers.

With Sportsman's Box, the three boxes will escalate in price from $25, $42 and $83 a month, with each plan being more and more "elite."

Because of this, Mystery Tackle Box is the immediate winner for anyone with zero interest in hunting and only wanting to focus on fishing.

On the opposite side of the argument, those that want to dip their toes into more than one hobby might find Sportsman's Box to be the clear winner just for the added variety that hunting gear can offer.

On a closing note, it's worth mentioning that their reviews are alarming low at 2.5 out of 5, according to Mysubscriptionaddiction.com.

Lucky Tackle Box

image via luckytacklebox

Lucky Tackle Box is the most direct competitor of Mystery Tackle Box in this short list. They offer a service remarkably similar in that both have three options for boxes. Additionally, both offer different species, and similar pricing plans at $16.99, $26.99, and $46, each billed monthly.

Still, Lucky Tackle Box mostly focuses on bass. In fact, only one option also allows for walleye. If you're focused in on bass fishing, then Lucky Tackle Box may be the better choice for you.

However, they don't come quite as highly recommended with a 7.5 out of 10, and their species options are highly limiting. Given that the two are so similar, there's not much reason to pick Lucky Tackle Box first.

Mystery Tackle Box Review: Reeling In

Ultimately, we're confident that Mystery Tackle Box is one of the best options out there. It offers a higher variety and quality than many of its competitors that offer similar services.

If you aren't aiming for the style of fishing that Mystery Tackle Box offers, some options may offer something better.

For example, dedicated fly fishers may want to focus on the PostFly as mentioned above. If you're a general angler just looking to add a bit more tackle to your box, then Mystery Tackle Box is likely to be the best option for you.

With everything said and done, Mystery Tackle Box is a high-quality service. It offers a fantastic option for dedicated fishers and amateur anglers alike. There's something for everyone inside of the box regardless of skill or hobby dedication.

Additionally, the general public touts it as one of the best options available. Anglers would do well to add this service to their fishing arsenal.

What do you think of the products mentioned here? Have you used them and made your own opinion already? Let us know in the comments below!

Featured Image via Pixabay

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This